Understanding the Current Insurance Market Challenges: What You Need to Know

Amber Ramirez, Owner Farmers Insurance Agency • June 26, 2024

Read highlights about the rapid and widespread tightening of the insurance marketplace affecting home and auto policies across various states, emphasizing increased premiums, policy restrictions, and strategic recommendations for navigating these industry shifts.

Many people are feeling the challenges of keeping up with recent insurance changes. I hope that you find the following information useful and that it helps explain what is happening in the insurance world today. It won't matter what carrier you are with; this is an industry-wide issue.


The insurance marketplace is tightening up, and it's happening fast. It's happening especially fast for home and auto insurance companies. This is regardless of what state you are in; however, California, Florida, Louisiana and Texas are being hit especially hard. Carriers are pulling a full hard stop on issuing any new policies across the country, and carriers that have NOT put a moratorium on binding new coverage are leaving the market or selling to other carriers/merging. They simply can't operate profitably in this inflationary market.


Every day, we hear about a pause on new business or a carrier putting a full stop on writing new policies. Some carriers require "full premium payment" up front for new business or a 20 to 30-day hold on new applications. Carriers may shift underwriting guidelines, so they "only want preferred business," no claims within five years (increased from 3 years), home and auto bundles, etc. Some carriers will NOT reinstate coverage if it lapses, no matter the reason.


The market is disrupted, and it will affect you. If it hasn't yet, it will. I have personally seen premiums double and triple what they were the year before.


The cost of claims has risen exponentially in the past two years, resulting in carriers having to raise premiums or pull out of some markets. In some states, carriers have applied for rate increases but have not been able to get them approved, so they simply shut down for new business.


If you have an auto or home insurance policy, your rates have gone up; if they haven't, they will. This isn't personal; it's not based on a claim you may or may not have had. It's simply the cost of doing business. If you have not received a rate increase, be prepared for one at your next renewal, if you get renewal terms at all.


  • The cost to rebuild your home is up dramatically due to the rising cost of materials and labor. The supply chain for materials continues to be an issue. We can all agree that everything has gone up in price. Carriers simply can't survive paying these higher prices without charging more themselves.
  • The cost to repair your car is up dramatically due to the rising cost of auto parts and labor to fix your car. In addition, parts in vehicles now include some technological features. Replacing a side mirror or windshield used to be $500 - now it's more than triple that.
  • The cost of medical care continues to skyrocket. Bodily injury in auto accidents is off the charts.
  • Litigation is expensive, and settlements are rising at an unprecedented rate.
  • Both the frequency and severity of auto accidents are WAY up post-COVID, along with the rising frequency of auto fatalities.
  • ReInsurance (the insurance your insurance carrier buys to help cushion catastrophic loss) is at or approaching capacity in many markets, and rising rates are unsustainable.


This is a significant issue affecting the property & casualty industry, and pricing correction is anticipated at least through 2024. It won't be for forever, but it is here now.


There are some things you can do to help get through these current insurance market challenges:


  • Consider higher deductibles. This will help save some money on your policy.
  • Safe Driving Telematic Programs: Telematics can reward you by giving you a discount for good driving.
  • Discount Reviews: Make sure you're getting everything you're entitled to. Every carrier has different discount opportunities. Go over those with your agent.
  • DO NOT let your policy cancel or lapse for any reason. Carriers are not reinstating coverage as easily as they once did. If it does cancel, they may require the premium to be paid in full before reinstating. This is across the board for every line of coverage.
  • Bundle your Auto and Home for more discounts and more stable pricing. Bundled/Packaged policies almost always include better coverage and benefits, and the savings is usually 10-15% (or more) on each policy. Many business risks can also bundle options.
  • Consider tenure. Jumping companies too often will hurt you in the long run. In addition, some carriers won't take you as a new client if you have less than two years with a carrier. More importantly, carriers are getting off some risks if a claim happens in the new business term or for the number of claims in a 3 to 5-year window. Tenure matters with a carrier.
  • Follow the laws so you don't get any tickets. Ticket charges really add to your policy and stay on your record for 3-5 years, depending on the carrier.
  • Absorb small claims when you're able and save coverage for catastrophic losses. Talk with your agent and let them claims counsel you should a loss happen. Stop using your towing or roadside assistance as a maintenance policy. Frequency of claims REALLY matters.


Lastly, please remember that we are agents for the carriers. We don't make the rules, we don't have control over the rates, and we don't decide if the carriers cancel your policy. We are here to help educate, make sure you have the best insurance for your situation, manage your account with the carrier, and claims counsel when needed. We are doing our best to manage carrier changes with client needs.


I hope this article explains some of what is happening in the insurance marketplace. Please be nice to your insurance agent - they are also taking the same increases, navigating carrier changes and doing their best to help you through this.


Thank you to some really smart agents who helped put this information together so it can be shared widely.


Our job is to ask you about your Life Insurance. Please don't make it our job to tell your family you didn't have any. Ask us how we can help you protect your family today!

By Tiffany Pressler February 19, 2025
February is the month of love, and the San Diego Country Estates Association is celebrating Thunder Matheny for her dedication and passion for her work.
By Amy Holsapple, Recreation Manager February 19, 2025
Get ready for an exciting season with Spring Break Camp, summer camp sign-ups, a festive Easter Egg Hunt, and a new shade cover at the Pocket Park—your Recreation Department has been busy planning fun for all!
By Matt Brumbaugh, PGA - Head Golf Professional February 19, 2025
San Vicente Golf Shop is ready to help golfers of all levels prepare for the season with the latest club demos, golf instruction, Twilight Golf events, and membership options.
Show More
Share by: